8 Top Websites and Apps for Selling Comic Books to Collectors Who Need Them

Image source: Jeff Whyte / Shutterstock

90% of selling something or finalizing a transaction requires conviction on your part. Do you have a worthy product to sell to someone who wants or needs it? Keep in mind the other 10% to finalizing 10% any sale is professional and non-desperate persuasion. If you know the buyer needs what you’re selling, you can almost sell on your terms. If you have old comic books or know how to source them free or cheaply, you could make a side hustle selling comic books.

Selling Comic Books on Your Terms

Social media and various comic book-based apps make it easier for novices to sell comics now. If you understand the value of the comics books you sell, the mindset of potential buyers, make connections, and hustle as much as possible, you could make some bank selling comic books.

In January 2022, a collector paid $3.3 million for page 25 of 1984’s Marvel Super Heroes Secret Wars #8. The collector paid to own the original page art from legendary artist Mike Zeck. You would have to have good connections, understand the value of the comics you sell, and understand the mindset of potential buyers to sell one page of art for so much money.

In October 2023, a Milwaukee, Wisconsin couple found an old copy of Amazing Fantasy #15. this comic features the first appearance of Spider-Man. Although the comic was not in the best condition, they might be able to sell it for $35,000.

I’m not promising that you’ll make millions, but you can definitely make a few bucks flipping comic books today. Digital commerce and social media make the process very feasible and convenient.

Here are eight top websites and apps for selling comic books.

1. FB Marketplace

You can use FB Marketplace, and the marketplaces of all your favorite social media platforms, to sell your comic books. You must take clear pics of the comics, list title and issue numbers, creator credits, and other vital info. Also, you need a basic understanding of the marketplace value of the comic to post a selling price.

Join numerous comic book groups and connect with local buyers. Slowly make connections and identify the most lkely buyers in your online marketplace area.Most importantly, you also need to be active on social media to identify groups and people to market your items for sale.

2. OfferUp

OfferUp is a free app that allows you to sell anything to other users relative to where you live. The app even suggests safe, public meeting spots to facilitate transactions between members.

All of these services are free on OfferUp if you do all of your own hustle work. However, if you choose to use a dedicated OfferUp listing for selling comic books, then the site will charge a 12.9% fee per sale. The minimum fee is $1.99.

3. eBay

You can sell anything on eBay auctions, so selling comic books is easy. There is a whole online industry on eBay for selling comic books.

Selling on eBay is free as long as you list 250 items or less for sale monthly. If you go over 250 items per month then you must pay 35 cents per item to list them. eBay also charges a 13.6% to 15% fee per final sale; this fee could be higher depending on the final sale amount.

4. My Comic Shop

My Comic Shop is the online retail store for Texas-based Lone Star Comics. The store is well-regarded for buying millions of vintage comic books annually. However, selling comic books here is only convenient if you own vintage comic books or have a large pedigree or estate sale collection of comics.

My Comic Shop prefers only buying comic books published in the 1970s or earlier, which they consider to be more valuable. You can also check the value of your comics against their online price guide and “want list.” The fees you pay per sale are relative to the value of the comics.

5. Heritage Auctions

Heritage Auctions is the industry leader and standard for experts selling comic books on consignment. Whenever you see that a rare comic book sells for millions, Heritage Comics usually handles the auction.

You send your comics to the company and their experts will evaluate, grade, slab, and even sell your comics at auction. The fees vary according to the value of the comic and the effort needed to sell them.

6. HipComic

HipComic is an online platform for selling comic books. They have an online network connected to over 50,000 comic book collectors and over 1 million online listings. You can even create your own online comic book store on HipComic to sell all of your comics. The site even has a comic scanner that you cna use to determine the value of your comics.

The monthly listing and auction fee varies according to the number of comics you list and their value. HipComic takes a 9.95% fee for each sale.

7. WhatNot

WhatNot is a live online auctioneering marketplace. It’s a live online marketplace where you will have to make videos and hold live auctioneering events for selling comic books. So, you can’t be shy.

Also, you should be developing a network of potential buyers in active social media groups for your efforts to be optimal. WhatNot charges an 8% sales fee along with a few other incremental processing fees depending on transaction amount.

8. ComicConnect

ComicConnect is an online platform for selling comic books with affordable fees. The site will charge you a fee ranging between 10% to 13% for every item sold. The company also offers free appraisals and low-cost fees for gradings.

If the company evaluates your comics and finds them to be rare, they could pay you a cash advance if you accept a lower deal. ComicConnect prefers transacting in comic books published in the 1970s and earlier.

Selling Comic Books

If you’re interested in selling comic books as a side hustle then you should prepare as much as possible. A car will not sell itself and neither do comic books, especially a valuable comic. Consult with friends or relatives who are comic book experts. You should at the very least look up the synopsis, plots, and creator info of each comic book you want to sell.

If you don’t know the value of the comics you want to sell, how can you optimize your profits? Make connections and talk to comic book experts to find potential buyers. Use social media to find potential collectors near you. Selling comics is not going to be a get-rich-quick scheme.

It will be really easy for you to get scammed if you don’t know anything about comics.

Basic Tips for Selling Comic Books

People who buy comics are nostalgic and understand the minutiae of comic book history. You should know the title, issue number, and all relevant information about the comics you want to sell.

You should consider grading and slabbing your most valuable comic books. This is the process of sending your comics to experts who grade and seal your comics. Your comics become verified, authenticated, and easier to sell.

Many sites will give you the basic marketplace value of your comic books after inputting the title, issue number, and creator names, usually for free. Some of the sites on this list have online price guides you can refer to.

Consider getting shipping insurance and signature confirmation for deliveries to protect against scams. You must pay fees for expert help or use a third-party facilitator platform when selling comic books. You must pay to ship your comics and have them evaluated and sold on consignment.

Start Small

Visit local small-scale comic book conventions to get a sense of how comic book collectors value the hobby. You could research digital copies of the comics you plan to buy and sell first. Think about investing in the best tablets to read comic books digitally for this purpose.

Your chances of selling comic books improve if you understand the hobby and culture, especially if you are a casual or non-reader.

This post includes affiliate links. If you purchase anything through these affiliated links, the author/website may earn a commission.

Hot topics

Finance

Marketing

Politics

Strategy