Bearaby Cotton Napper Review 2025

After testing a bunch of hefty throws and comforters for our best weighted blanket guide, I consider myself a bit of a weighted blanket aficionado. While research supporting the efficacy of weighted blankets to fight stress and anxiety is limited, subjectively, I love using them to help me wind down at the end of a long day and ease myself to sleep. All in all, weighted blankets are a wonderful addition to your bed or couch.

There’s one problem, though: most weighted blankets are more concerned with function over style, making them look a little awkward and unfashionable in your living room or bedroom. But, in comes the Bearaby Cotton Napper: a chunky, knitted weighted blanket that looks natural draped across my couch. Out of all the blankets I’ve tried, Bearaby has earned the coveted spot on my couch because of its combination of form and function. It’s the best weighted blanket we’ve tried — and for good reason.

What I like

It looks like a regular throw blanket, and its heft comes from knitted fabric, not glass beads.

The Bearaby Cotton Napper is a knitted weighted blanket, meaning that its heft comes from the heavyweight yarn, rather than glass or metal beads that you’ll usually find in a traditional weighted blanket.

The knit design is ideal for a couple of reasons. First, you don’t have to worry about feeling individual beads pressing into your body as you try to relax or fall asleep, or the awkward rustling of beads moving as you shift positions. Second, it looks like a traditional, cozy throw blanket, so you’re not sacrificing style for calming pressure.

It comes in a ton of variations to suit almost any style or bed size.

The Cotton Napper is available in a slew of weights and sizes, ranging from 10 pounds at 40 x 64 inches to 25 pounds at 48 x 72 inches. Bearaby recommends that you choose a blanket that’s about 10% of your body weight. It’s available in 10 neutral colors like a creamy beige and a pastel forest green, and a recently released variant called Sailboat features thick green-and-blue stripes.

There’s also a Tencel variant of the Napper, specifically designed to keep hot sleepers comfortable (and it’s available in a gorgeous lavender shade). If you’re looking for a bigger blanket than a throw, Bearaby also sells queen-size and king-size blankets that fit on the bed.

It’s (sort of) machine washable, and you might be able to buy it with HSA/FSA dollars.

Care-wise, while all sizes of the Cotton Napper are machine-washable, we don’t recommend washing blankets 20 pounds or above at home, since the weight can damage your washer and dryer. Instead, we recommend taking heavy Cotton Nappers to a professional laundry service for cleaning. Lighter blankets can be washed in cold water and tumble dried on low, but Bearaby warns against hanging the blanket to dry, since this can stretch out the loops. Since I got the 25-pound version, I haven’t washed the blanket at home. But, I’ve been able to spot treat it with no problem. It picks up dog hair (but in my house, what doesn’t?), but I haven’t noticed any stains or durability issues. Read our guide on how to wash a weighted blanket.

Finally, if you have an eligible medical condition like chronic pain or a sleep disorder, you can use HSA/FSA funds to buy a Bearaby Cotton Napper. Bearaby partners with TrueMed to help customers get a letter of medical necessity and check out using their pre-tax dollars.

It’s incredibly cozy and doesn’t get too hot.

After getting the Cotton Napper out of the bag, I was impressed with its feel. The fabric is smooth yet soft, like a worn-in jersey T-shirt. After unboxing, the blanket gave off a slight plasticky smell, which mostly dissipated after use. Still, if I bury my face in the blanket, I can still smell a slight, swimming-pool-like scent.

I’m a plus-size person, so I opted for the heaviest blanket at 25 pounds. It’s not quite 10% of my body weight, like Bearaby recommends, but the blanket is still comfortable with a pleasant, gentle pressure. I’ve taken many, many cozy naps under it. I genuinely feel like it helps to fight off the stress — I find myself reaching for it when I’m hanging out on the couch playing a game or watching a movie. I feel relaxed when I use it, so it’s my go-to after a long day.

The open weave of the knit helps with breathability. I’m a hot sleeper and all-around sweaty person, but I’ve never overheated under this blanket. The fabric is cool-to-the-touch, too, so it even helps cool me down.

On top of the cozy feel, it looks nice, too. I tried the navy color, a deep blue that stands out against my gray couch. It looks just like any chunky, knit throw blanket, and much nicer than a weighted blanket with baffle-box construction.

The Bearaby Cotton Napper has a 30-day trial and a one-year warranty. As long as your blanket hasn’t been washed, you can return it within 30 days for a refund or exchange. You will have to pay a $19.99 return fee, though. The one-year warranty was introduced in June 2025, covering workmanship defects or flaws for a year after purchase.

Where it falls short

While the knit weave looks nice and makes the blanket breathable, my fingers and toes got caught in the loops. It didn’t bother my sleep, but it feels a little uncomfortable. The open weave also means it’s not the best blanket for keeping warm.

Otherwise, I also noticed a slight, plasticky smell after unboxing the blanket that has slightly remained after months of use. The heavier versions can technically be washed at home, but be warned that the weight could damage your washer and dryer.

What are your alternatives?

For another attractive, knit weighted blanket, I recommend the Silk & Snow Hand Knitted Weighted Blanket. It has the same construction as the Cotton Napper, but with a more relaxed yarn and a more affordable price point. I did notice that the loops stretch out on the Silk & Snow blanket, though. Read our Bearaby vs Silk & Snow weighted blanket comparison.

For other recommendations, including heated weighted blankets and weighted comforters, check out our best weighted blanket guide.

The bottom line

I love the Bearaby Cotton Napper, and I firmly believe that it has earned its spot as the best weighted blanket. It’s ridiculously comfortable, especially compared to other weighted blankets that use heavy beads as a filling. As a hot sleeper, I appreciate that the fabric is cool to the touch and the open weave is breathable — even if my fingers and toes do get stuck in the loops from time to time. It has earned its spot on my couch, where it will stay, looking as cozy and inviting as ever.