Republicans and Democrats Are in Revolt – For Very Different Reasons

America’s 250^th anniversary is defined by one undeniable fact: Both sides of the aisle are in open revolt against elites. Nothing would make the founders more proud. They created this country through their own act of rebellion against an out-of-touch ruling class. But it’s far from clear whether today’s elites will be fully defeated – or if the country is doomed to suffer under another self-serving ruling class.

On the right, at least, the revolt has been underway for a decade. Before 2016, Republican voters had repeatedly backed go-along-to-get-along politicians – the Romneys, McCains, and Bushes of the world. In return, they got mountains of debt-and-deficit spending, multiple unwinnable wars, and massive expansions in the size and power of government. Rather than clean up the country’s messes, the GOP elite made them worse, while creating new crises and tolerating corruption.

Out of sheer frustration, Republicans turned against their ruling class, throwing their support behind Donald Trump. He has since demolished the GOP establishment. While the Trump revolution is still underway in policy, on the political front, it’s over. The old Republican elite is never coming back.

Then there’s the open revolt on the left. Like the frustrated Republicans of a decade ago, today’s Democrats are furious at their elected official for the lack of change. But whereas the right is fighting to return quintessential American values to the fore, these leftists want to ditch those values altogether. Their vision can be summed up in one word: socialism.

Hence the stunning victory of Zohran Mamdani in New York City. Hence the rising star of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez in Congress and socialist candidates in congressional primaries. And hence the deluge of socialist activists coming out of college campuses. They’re sick and tired of Democratic elites who don’t do anything with their power. They’re determined to seize that power for themselves.

Say this for the current anti-elite moment: It’s beautifully American. Both the right and left are breathing new life into our national ideal of sovereignty, which holds that the people are ultimately in control. It’s good to remind ourselves – and our would-be rulers – that we the people are still in charge.

But not all revolts are created equal. Despite their superficial similarity, the Republican and Democrat versions are diametrically opposed and fundamentally incompatible. At the end of the day, the right is trying to permanently give power back to the people. The left, on the other hand, is setting the stage to create a permanent – and much worse – ruling class.

The difference between these two revolts is clear in the kinds of policies they back. On the right, Republicans from Donald Trump down are fighting to gut unelected bureaucracies, give families the direct funding to choose their children’s education, and slash red tape and taxes to unleash small business formation and job creation. Their immigration crackdown is also rooted in sovereignty, insofar as it rolls back the blatant elite attempts to prop up their power by bringing in potential foreign voters. On issue after issue, Republicans are taking power from elites and giving it to the people.

The socialist wave is rushing in the opposite direction. Today’s leftists want government control over virtually every facet of the economy, vast expansions of the welfare state that can be paid for only by middle-class tax hikes; and unprecedented power in the hands of unelected bureaucrats. Realizing this vision necessarily means restricting power to a fortunate few. As history attests, socialism creates a ruling class that runs roughshod over everyone else, since absolute power corrupts absolutely.

Only one of these revolts will ultimately be good for the American people – and the wrong one has the momentum. Democratic Socialists are surging in local, state, and national elections, while Republicans are doubting themselves instead of doubling down on their agenda. Republicans are also wondering if their revolt can survive once Trump leaves office after the 2028 election. But they should be working to ensure it does, rallying around leaders who will keep taking the fight to our would-be overlords.

In this time of revolt, there’s no guarantee of who will win. But the same was true 250 years ago, at America’s birth. The battle then was very much between the revolutionaries who stood for the people and those who stood for the elites. The founders led their fellow Americans to cast off the shackles of that ruling class. Now Republicans must rally the people once again to ensure another 250 years of sovereignty and national success.