Size range: 3.5-14, including half sizes, in narrow, medium, and wide widths
Though aesthetically simple, flats are actually a complicated design to nail, especially in terms of comfort. With “a rounded toe, functional bow that tightens for a custom fit, and soft leather that molds to your feet,” Margaux’s Demi ballet flat is the rare, perfectly snug case that doesn’t gap or use uncomfy elastics to stay put, writes executive editor Sally Kaplan. “It’s perfect in every way, save for the slight blister it gave me on my heel the first day I broke them in (and no days after that). There’s just enough cushioning for me to feel supported when commuting, but not so much that the shoe loses its unstructured, simple aesthetic.”
Handmade in Spain, the Italian nappa leather flats come in 24 half sizes and three widths, though we found they run a touch small and slightly narrow. They’re among the best flats we’ve tested, available in 16 colors and patterns, including two woven styles. “They’re also just adorable,” adds former beauty editor Maiya Pascouche. “I love how they look with my more tailored looks and casual, everyday outfits.”
Honorable mention: FitFlop Delicato
Despite FitFlop’s disclaimer that these run slim, we found these smooth, unstructured leather flats to fit quite loose above the toes. Thanks to a ‘Dynamicush’ footbed made from squishy foam, a roomy squared-off toe box, and a flexible collar that prevents any uncomfortable friction, they’ve become our favorite ballet flats for wide feet.
