Where to Find Unique Gifts Online: 17 Websites to Know

Shop unique gifts at Mark & Graham

Best for: Tastefully monogrammed gifts

For a high-quality gift with a touch of personalization, look no further than Mark & Graham. The brand can monogram anything from custom leather handbags to cheeseboards, making a genuinely useful gift a little more special.

Shop customizable gifts at Abbode

Best for: Custom embroidery

Almost everything from Abbode — a NYC-based small business — can be customized with embroidery. You can add a monogram to a vegan crocodile pouch, memorialize a special family recipe on a tea towel, or emblazon a pillowcase with with a loved one’s initals. The brand also has plenty of pre-set designs to choose from, whether you want to add a tiny martini glass to a set of cocktail napkins or a bow to a pair of lacy undies.

Shop unique gifts at Uncommon Goods

Best for: Fun, unusual gifts

As the name suggests, Uncommon Goods specializes in more unusual products, whether it’s a QR code mug with a daily dad joke, an edible butter candle kit, or pajamas you can color on. It even has virtual classes you can gift, ranging in topics from a couple’s map-making class to astrology readings.

Shop personalized books at Wonderbly

Best for: Personalized books with minimal effort

Wonderbly is a website that creates giftable, personalized books for all ages and interests — from kids’ stories to cookbooks. Personalizing a book for your recipient only takes a few minutes, and the site guides you through the process with prompts and questions. The result is a keepsake you can make in minutes that still feels unique and special.

Shop unique gifts at Flamingo Estate

Best for: Highly curated, slow-living little luxuries

Flamingo Estate started as a collection of sundries from one man’s California home and has grown into a brand focused on bespoke, expertly sourced and crafted delights for the home and kitchen. You’ll find plenty of beautifully packaged items with a small-batch, California-local focus. Some favorite finds include a bottle of California olive oil that can be customized with a hand-written label, its viral Roma tomato candle, and Pamela Anderson’s own pickles.

Shop unique gifts at Etsy

Best for: Highly specific, original gifts

Whether you want a non-corporate greeting card, a digital couples portrait, or a personalized sweater, Etsy probably has every gift you could possibly come up with.

Shop unique gifts at Goldbelly

Best for: Gifts for foodies

Rather than offer gift baskets of snacks, Goldbelly ships regional foods all over the country, whether it’s Maine lobster rolls or Memphis BBQ. If you don’t want to send food directly to the recipient, you can also opt for a simple gift card and let them pick what they’re craving.

Read our review of Goldbelly here.

Shop unique gifts at the MET Museum Store

Best for: Arty, curated gifts

The Metropolitan Museum of Art boasts one of the best art collections in the world, so it’s no surprise that its gift store offers an equally curated array of gifts at surprisingly affordable price points. You’ll find beautiful, arty gifts for all ages, including jewelry, prints, and coffee table books.

Shop men’s gifts at Bespoke Post

Best for: Unique gifts for men

Like Wolf & Badger, Bespoke Post is an online marketplace of small brands, but with a focus on items for men. You’ll find dedicated pages of axes, knives, and tools alongside top-quality kitchenware and home decor. The brand also offers a curated subscription box, in case you’d like someone else to do the shopping for you.

Shop unique gifts at Shutterfly

Best for: High-resolution photo gifts

Whether you want to create a straightforward photo book or an elaborate three-piece wall photo, Shutterfly is one of our favorite places to make custom gifts out of photos. The photo editor is incredibly simple to use — all you need is high-res photos to upload. 

Shop unique gifts at Coming Soon

Best for: Truly unique, arty home pieces

Imagine if the coolest art friend you know opened a boutique: that’s the vibe of Coming Soon, an NYC-based gift and homewares store. Color, playfulness, and curved lines are the basis for most of the shop’s items, including a pill bottle-shaped wine cooler and whimsical glassware. The shop also sells some small delights, too like a rainbow kitchen sponge, a $30 surprise ball shaped like an orange and a $5 brat-inspired lighter.

Shop independent brands at Wolf & Badger

Best for: Unique finds from small brands

Wolf & Badger is an online marketplace where small, independent brands from around the world can sell their products to a global audience. Think of it as an online department store specifically for small brands: It’s a great destination to discover unique products, including handmade and artisan gifts, festive decor, and clothing for men and women. No matter the category, you’re bound to find something you’ve never seen before, like charming cottage-core designs from Fable England or silly kitchenware from Jimbobart.

Shop unique gifts at Greetabl

Best for: Fully customizable gift boxes

Using Greetabl’s simple gift builder, you can craft a custom gift box in minutes by selecting everything from the packaging to what goes inside. You can choose from an assortment of things like candles, candy, skincare products, gift cards, and other small trinkets like keychains or socks.

Shop unique gifts at Ten Thousand Villages

Best for: Ethically-sourced, globally-inspired gifts

Ten Thousand Villages is a non-profit, fair trade organization that sources its wares from more than 20,000 skilled artisans across 30 countries. Globally-minded giftees will appreciate its sustainable gifts, like carved gourd earings from Peru and baskets woven in Vietnam.

Shop unique gifts at Personalization Mall

Best for: Maximum gift personalization 

Personalization Mall fits its name perfectly: it offers a wide array of products — from blankets to wind chimes — that you can customize with someone’s name, photos, or a special message.

Shop unique gifts at Minted

Best for: Stationery and wall art

Whether you want a simple, cute greeting card or a unique wrapping paper, Minted has both already-made stationery and home decor and some customization options. It’s also great for specific collections, such as wedding gifts and Disney art.

Shop unique gifts at MoMA Design Store

Best for: Colorful, design-focused gifts

NYC’s Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) has one of the best gift stores in the world and you can shop all of it online. The selection is highly curated: each item is assessed against MoMA’s eight criteria of good design before it is included in the store’s offerings. While you’ll find plenty of books and art prints, there’s also a strong focus on lifestyle items that blend form and function.