THE GIST
The European auto industry is a high-stakes game of bumper cars. Stellantis and Volkswagen both dropped first-quarter results that should have been celebratory but instead left investors hitting the brakes.
Despite massive earnings beats and improved cash flows, shares are tumbling as the market stares down the headlights of a “very messy” future defined by trade wars, Chinese competition, and geopolitical gridlock.
WHAT HAPPENED
Thursday was a tale of two titans trying to outrun a cooling global economy. Stellantis, the parent of Jeep and Ram, reported a near tripling of its adjusted operating income to €960 million. This crushed analyst expectations of €568 million, fueled by a resurgence in the US market where the Hemi V8 engine is proving to be a surprising lifeline.
However, the stock still tanked as much as 10% because the earnings “quality” was brought into question. A significant chunk of that profit came from a €400 million US tariff refund following a Supreme Court ruling, masking what would have been a negative margin in North America.
Volkswagen is facing a steeper climb. The German giant reported a 14.3% drop in operating profit to €2.5 billion, missing the €4 billion mark analysts were looking for. While sales revenue hit €75.7 billion, the company is being squeezed by an annualized €4 billion headwind from US tariffs and a brutal 15% delivery slump in China.
VW CEO Oliver Blume was blunt, citing “wars, trade barriers, and intense competition” as the primary reasons for the skid. To survive, VW is now doubling down on a painful restructuring plan that includes shedding 50,000 jobs by the end of the decade.
WHY IT MATTERS
The reason investors are fleeing despite “beats” is that the underlying mechanics of these businesses look increasingly fragile. We are moving out of an era where carmakers could rely on infinite growth in China and stable trade with the US.
Our analysts just identified a stock with the potential to be the next Nvidia. Tell us how you invest and we’ll show you why it’s our #1 pick. Tap here.
For Stellantis, the reliance on the US market is a double-edged sword. While they are gaining market share (up to 7.9% in the US), they are doing so by leaning heavily into gas-guzzling V8s and hybrids at a time when regulatory pressure is supposedly pushing the other way. Analysts at Citi called the results “very messy” because the company remains free cash flow negative to the tune of €1.9 billion.
Essentially, Stellantis is growing, but it is burning through cash to do it, and it needed a legal win on tariffs to make the math look pretty.
