Quick Read
ISPY’s 0.56% fee and daily call-writing cost holders roughly 3 percentage points of annual upside versus the index in a rising market.
SPY beat ISPY by over 2 points YTD; VOO tracks the same 500 stocks at a fraction of the cost with no upside cap.
ISPY’s return-of-capital distributions defer taxes by shrinking your cost basis, creating a larger taxable gain when you eventually sell.
It sounds nuts, but SoFi1 is giving new Active Invest users up to $3,000 in stock for a limited time, and all it takes is a $50 deposit to get started.2 See for yourself (Sponsor)
Every time the ProShares S&P 500 High Income ETF (CBOE:ISPY) writes another daily call option, holders swap tomorrow’s gains for today’s yield. That swap comes at a price. It just does not show up on the marketing page next to the headline dividend rate.
What You’re Actually Paying
ISPY carries a 0.56% annual expense ratio. On $10,000 invested, that is roughly $56 straight out of your return every year. For the same 500 companies underneath, SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) and Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA:VOO) charge only a fraction of that. Compound the fee gap on $10,000 over 20 years at broad market-like returns and the pure expense drag runs into four figures.
The fee is the visible cost. The bigger bill is the one buried in the strategy itself: daily call-writing means maximum income, maximum upside sacrifice.
The Part the Factsheet Doesn’t Highlight
Let’s look at what the daily covered call did in a rising market. Year to date through August 6th, ISPY returned 10.4% while SPY returned 12.71%. Over the past year, ISPY posted 18.93% against SPY’s 21.46%. The gap is the upside you sold for premium income. A sister ProShares prospectus describes the mechanism plainly: an options overlay “designed to provide exposure similar to owning the Underlying Security while generating option premiums, which may limit upside returns.”
SoFi Active Invest is offering a limited-time promotion. Open an account, fund it with $50 or more, and you could receive up to $3,000 in complimentary stock for Active Invest accounts. See for yourself by clicking here now. (Sponsor)
Then there is the tax issue. ISPY’s distributions are “largely tax-efficient, primarily funded by return of capital”. However, return of capital only defers tax. As such, ROC reduces your cost basis, which means a larger capital gain (or smaller loss) when you sell. You are simply deferring tax. Additionally, the “income” itself is lumpy: a $1.274928 payout in May 2025 was followed by $0.04531 three months later. If you planned to build a monthly budget on the yield, the fund has complicated that for you.
