Holding a high-yield dividend portfolio in a taxable account at the 24% federal bracket means writing the IRS a $14,400 check every year on $60,000 of income that should have been yours. It repeats annually, forever, on the same dollars you already earned.
This series exists because most readers know what a Roth IRA is but have never run the actual dollar delta on the specific high-yield names they own. The basket below is built from ten tickers that pay mostly ordinary-income distributions, which is exactly where Roth placement matters most.
The Tax Delta: Roth Versus Taxable on a $60,000 Income Portfolio
Assume a roughly $1 million portfolio split evenly across ten high-yield names. Current yields pulled from each company’s most recent dividend declarations:
Stock | Current Yield | Tax Character |
|---|---|---|
British American Tobacco (NYSE:BTI) | 5% | Qualified dividend; subject to 15% UK withholding tax that a Roth cannot recover |
Altria (NYSE:MO) | 6% | Qualified |
AbbVie (NYSE:ABBV) | 3% | Qualified |
Verizon (NYSE:VZ) | 6% | Qualified |
AT&T (NYSE:T) | 4% | Ordinary income |
Realty Income (NYSE:O) | 5% | Ordinary (REIT) |
Ares Capital (NASDAQ:ARCC) | 10% | Ordinary (BDC) |
Main Street Capital (NYSE:MAIN) | 8% | Ordinary (BDC) |
Enterprise Products Partners (NYSE:EPD) | 6% | K-1, ordinary plus return of capital; UBTI considerations apply inside an IRA above $1,000 annually |
JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (NYSEARCA:JEPI) | 8% | Largely ordinary (option premium) |
Ares Capital declared $0.48 quarterly, Main Street pays $0.26 monthly plus a $0.30 quarterly supplemental, and EPD distributes $0.55 per unit quarterly. Blended together the basket produces roughly $60,000 in gross annual income on $1 million invested.
Inside a Roth, that $60,000 lands in the account untouched. In a taxable account at the 24% bracket, $14,400 leaves for the IRS and the investor nets $45,600. Over a flat 10 years with no growth assumed, that is $144,000 of permanent tax cost.
The Bracket Multiplier
The Roth advantage scales directly with marginal rate. Same basket, same $60,000 gross, different bracket:
The analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 stocks and Ares Capital wasn’t one of them. Get them here FREE.
Federal Bracket | Annual Tax | Taxable Net | Roth Net | Annual Roth Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
22% | $13,200 | $46,800 | $60,000 | $13,200 |
24% | $14,400 | $45,600 | $60,000 | $14,400 |
32% | $19,200 | $40,800 | $60,000 | $19,200 |
37% | $22,200 | $37,800 | $60,000 | $22,200 |
State income tax is not included. Add it on top and the gap widens further.
Why These Names Specifically
Most S&P 500 dividends are qualified and taxed at preferential rates. The basket above is different. BDCs like Ares Capital and Main Street Capital are required to distribute substantially all taxable income to shareholders, taxed at ordinary rates. REIT dividends from Realty Income are characterized as ordinary income. JEPI’s covered-call premium income flows through as non-qualified. AT&T’s distribution is treated as ordinary income for many holders.
